The Modern Arab Intellectual Forsakes Ideological Integrity, Following the Footsteps of Previous Enemies Who Accuse Him of Takfir and Treason
Were I to sum up Amin Zaoui’s position on the Arab leftist intellectuals, who nowadays are considered part of the mumanah alliance — that is, Arab intellectuals who support the positions of Iran, Hezbollah, Syria, Iraq, and Yemen — a word of caution about the terminology used must be clarified: a distinction exists between today’s leftists and those of the 1960s, 1970s, and even part of the 1980s. Today’s leftists tend to be vulgar and lack the theoretical sophistication of their previous iterations. These critiques by Amin Zaoui, an Algerian novelist and essayist whose commentaries appear weekly in Independent Arabia, analyze the two mumanah generations, particularly emphasizing the contemporary generation of leftists who grew up in the new millennium and its current trends.
The two articles in reference appeared in Independent Arabia (“The Tragedy of the Arab Left Intellectuals,” November 23, 2023 and “The Hostility of Intellectuals Towards Each Other,” September 14, 2023). His criticisms can be easily categorized within neoconservative traditions that gained popularity during the second Bush administration and the Iraq War. While the earlier generation of Arab leftist intellectuals (whose intellectual caliber surpasses today’s intellectuals despite undergoing generational differences), the disparity between then and now is stark; current mumanah discourse is marked by ideological weakness, with leftist intellectuals itching to stamp their seals of approval on Hezbollah and allies’ policies in Lebanon and elsewhere.
Zaoui exposes the Arab leftist intellectual as caught between two opposing forces: the political dictatorial authority and the religious one, represented by the Faqih. Irrespective of which one dominates, both are the antithesis of the intellectual Zaoui has in mind: the democratic-oriented intellectual, secular and tolerant of the other.
“An Algerian Intellectual on Once-‘Arab Leftist Radicals’! The Modern Arab Intellectual Forsakes Ideological Integrity, Following the Footsteps of Previous Enemies Who Accuse Him of Takfir and Treason” by Elie Chalala is scheduled to appear in the forthcoming Al Jadid, Vol. 28, No. 85, 2024.
Subscribe to Al Jadid Digital for $15.95 to read the full article (1,354 words). Subscribers gain access to Al Jadid’s online archive, which includes 21 years of Al Jadid Magazine issues and the last three years of Inside Al Jadid Reports:
If you are a student and your library is not subscribed to Al Jadid, contact your library to subscribe to Al Jadid’s institutional subscription:
If you are interested in purchasing print copies of Al Jadid Magazine (Nos. 42-75), contact us at aljadid@aljadid.com or by mail:
Al Jadid Magazine
5762 Lincoln Ave. #1005
Cypress, CA 90630
Copyright © 2024 AL JADID MAGAZINE